South Australia Premier Peter Malinauskas is facing significant backlash over his decision to award a contract for the redesign of North Adelaide Golf Course to Greg Norman Golf Course Design without a public tender. The move has sparked criticism, particularly due to Norman’s association with the controversial LIV Golf, a Saudi-backed tour that has divided the golfing community.
Critics argue that Malinauskas, who has a reputation for promoting major sporting events like the AFL’s Gather Round, is overstepping his authority by taking control of the council-managed course. The decision to bypass a tender process has raised questions about transparency and governance under his leadership.
Controversial Contract Award
The South Australian government, led by Malinauskas and his Labor party, awarded the redesign contract directly to Greg Norman’s company, citing its specialized skills and reputation. However, this decision has been met with criticism from various quarters, including crossbench MP Frank Pangallo, who described the move as “arrogant” and indicative of governmental hubris.
Pangallo expressed concerns about the government’s unchecked power, stating, “This government needs to be held to account. They really do and unfortunately, they’re not.” He also highlighted pressing issues such as cost of living and healthcare that remain unaddressed, overshadowed by the government’s focus on high-profile events.
Government’s Justification and Response
State Urban Development Minister Nick Champion defended the decision, emphasizing the need for swift action to redevelop the course for LIV Golf. “We’re taking a golf course and it’s becoming an even better golf course,” Champion stated, dismissing critics as “focused on process” rather than outcomes.
The government has pledged $1.7 billion over five years to address public health system demands, yet critics argue that such investments are overshadowed by the controversy surrounding the golf course redevelopment.
Impact on Local Governance
The announcement of the government’s takeover of the golf course blindsided Adelaide’s City Council, with Lord Mayor Jane Lomax-Smith expressing frustration over the lack of collaboration. The council, which has managed the course for over a century, was in discussions with the government to bring LIV Golf closer to the city center.
“Our investment is being removed and … this is not a particularly collaborative way to do business,” Lomax-Smith remarked, highlighting the council’s longstanding stewardship of the parklands.
Broader Implications and Future Prospects
The redevelopment of the North Adelaide Golf Course, estimated to cost at least $45 million, aims to transform the site into a world-class venue for LIV Golf events, which are contracted to remain in Adelaide until 2031. However, concerns persist about the financial sustainability and environmental impact of the project.
Pangallo raised questions about the potential increase in membership fees and maintenance costs, noting, “This is going to cost the state a lot of money to maintain. Who’s going to maintain it? Where is the money going to come from?”
Despite these concerns, the government remains optimistic about the economic benefits of hosting such events. The recent LIV Golf event at a suburban course reportedly generated an $81 million windfall for the state.
Environmental and Economic Considerations
While the exact number of new constructions and tree removals remains uncertain, Champion assured that for every tree removed, three more would be planted. The redevelopment is seen as a catalyst for attracting additional events, including women’s golf tournaments, thereby boosting local tourism and investment.
“This will bring life and activity and investment to our parklands,” Champion asserted, underscoring the government’s vision for a vibrant and economically prosperous Adelaide.
As the debate continues, the Malinauskas administration faces the challenge of balancing economic ambitions with transparency and environmental stewardship, as Adelaide prepares to host LIV Golf events from 2028.
