The Miami Dolphins have made a significant decision regarding their quarterback position, opting to bench Tua Tagovailoa for the final three weeks of the 2025 NFL season. This comes after the Dolphins fell to a disappointing 6-8 record, effectively eliminating them from playoff contention. Despite Tagovailoa’s hefty contract, reportedly exceeding $50 million annually, the team has chosen to start rookie Quinn Ewers, a seventh-round draft pick, in his place.
Tagovailoa’s performance this season has drawn scrutiny, particularly due to his league-high 15 interceptions. The decision to bench him has reignited discussions about his past relationship with former Dolphins head coach Brian Flores, who is currently the defensive coordinator for the Minnesota Vikings. Flores faced criticism for his treatment of Tagovailoa during their time together, with reports indicating that he often expressed dissatisfaction with the quarterback’s performance.
On his podcast, “Fully Loaded,” Hall of Famer Cris Carter commented on the ongoing narrative, stating, “Everything Brian Flores said about Tua is true.” Carter believes that Flores may have been delivering the right messages but to the wrong audience. He pointed out the implications of Ewers stepping in as the starting quarterback, emphasizing the unusual nature of a seventh-round pick replacing a highly compensated player.
Carter’s remarks reflect a broader sentiment surrounding the dynamics between Flores and Tagovailoa during their shared tenure in Miami. When Flores was dismissed in early 2022, many speculated that his contentious relationship with Tagovailoa played a role in the decision. This speculation was further fueled by Tagovailoa’s public criticism of Flores, where he described the coach as a “terrible person” who consistently undermined his confidence.
In a subsequent press conference, Flores acknowledged Tagovailoa’s comments, expressing a desire to improve as a coach while maintaining his high standards. He stated, “I’m always going to correct, I’m always going to have a high standard,” indicating his commitment to fostering growth in his players.
Despite a Pro Bowl season in 2023, questions linger about Tagovailoa’s long-term viability as a franchise quarterback. Observers suggest that had the Dolphins supported Flores’ approach at the time, they might have avoided the situation that now sees Tagovailoa benched and Ewers taking center stage.
As the Dolphins navigate the final weeks of the season, the focus remains on how this decision will impact both Tagovailoa’s career and the team’s future trajectory. The dynamics between the players and coaching staff will be crucial as they seek to rebuild and define their identity moving forward.
