A resident of Clontarf, Australia, is at the center of a community dispute after her initiative to create a street library was deemed “illegal” by the Moreton Bay Council. Melissa Forbes erected a book-sharing box in January 2023, inviting local residents to “give a book, take a book.” This simple act of goodwill quickly turned contentious when a complaint led to an unexpected visit from council officials.
Forbes, who intended to foster a sense of community, was informed that her book box required a permit and $20 million in public liability insurance if approved. Despite submitting her application, it was ultimately denied. “I was a little surprised at the level of bureaucracy required,” Forbes noted, reflecting on the situation that has drawn significant attention.
According to a spokesperson from the Moreton Bay Council, while street libraries serve as valuable community assets, Forbes’ installation obstructed pathways and posed potential safety risks. “The book box had unfortunately been constructed in line with a bus shelter and footpath obstructing people’s movements,” the spokesperson stated.
Understanding the council’s regulations, Forbes acknowledged the importance of safety but felt the rules were perhaps misapplied in her case. “It did feel like a well-intentioned rule gone wrong,” she remarked. “It’s hard to develop community culture when things like this happen.”
The community of Clontarf rallied around Forbes in support of her library. Letters were sent to the council, and an online petition was launched, gathering hundreds of signatures from residents and supporters as far away as the United Kingdom and Serbia. “People really do care about small, joyful community things,” Forbes said, touched by the overwhelming response. “When you give the community a reason to show up, they really do.”
After seven months, the book nook was relocated and secured to her fence, complying with council standards while still serving its purpose. The initiative has now been humorously rebranded, with “illegal book box” prominently displayed on the side. “We are pleased the library was moved closer to the fence line as council suggested so as not to impede access and can continue to be enjoyed by the community,” the council spokesperson confirmed.
Forbes has since embraced her role as an unofficial advocate for street libraries. She expressed gratitude for the community support and mentioned that her local councillor has begun advocating for clearer guidelines around street library installations. “Hopefully, the next person won’t have to navigate the same issue,” she stated.
Reflecting on the journey, Forbes emphasized the importance of community engagement and collaboration. “The biggest surprise was seeing how much people cared,” she said. “It helped spark a bigger conversation around what kind of communities we want to build.” For those considering similar projects, her advice is straightforward: “Check your local council laws first.”
The story of Melissa Forbes serves not only as a reminder of the challenges of community initiatives but also underscores the power of collective action in addressing local concerns.
