As the NFL season progresses, several teams are grappling with the difficult decision of whether to retain their starting quarterbacks. This week, coaches from various franchises faced scrutiny over their quarterback choices, with performances leading to discussions about potential changes.
The New Orleans Saints, currently with a record of 1-6, are contemplating their future after a disappointing loss to the Chicago Bears. Head coach Kellen Moore confirmed that starting quarterback Spencer Rattler will remain in his role, despite a dismal performance where Rattler threw three interceptions and lost a fumble. Moore described the situation as a “week-to-week thing,” indicating that while Rattler retains his position for now, the door is open for future evaluations.
Over in New York, the Jets find themselves at the bottom of the league with a 0-7 record. Coach Aaron Glenn is under pressure to make a decision regarding quarterback Justin Fields, who has struggled significantly. Fields has recorded a career-low 32.1 Total QBR, ranking 31st among qualified quarterbacks. His performance has raised concerns, as he has averaged fewer than four yards per pass attempt in his last two games.
The Jets face the challenge of balancing their investment in Fields—who received a guaranteed $30 million on a two-year contract—with the need to secure a win. Alternate quarterback Tyrod Taylor is on the roster, but his tendency for turnovers could complicate matters. Glenn noted the need to evaluate Fields’ execution while also considering the offensive struggles contributing to the Jets’ winless season.
In Minnesota, the Vikings are also weighing their options. With a record of 3-3, head coach Kevin O’Connell must decide whether to continue with Carson Wentz, who has shown flashes of potential but is currently performing below expectations with a 42.9 QBR. The Vikings have a critical game against the Los Angeles Chargers this Thursday, leaving limited time to prepare. There is interest in giving rookie J.J. McCarthy game experience, but his recovery from injury may delay that decision.
Meanwhile, the Saints are looking towards the future after their latest setback. With Rattler’s struggles evident—he has never surpassed 300 passing yards in a game—there is speculation about the readiness of Tyler Shough as a possible alternative. The Saints, projected to have the No. 3 pick in the upcoming draft, may wish to assess their options at quarterback before making significant roster decisions.
Finally, the Las Vegas Raiders are dealing with their own quarterback issues. Current starter Geno Smith has faced criticism for his performance, including a league-high 10 interceptions. Although rookie Kenny Pickett made his debut in a recent game, his first play resulted in a fumble, raising concerns about his readiness to take over. Coach Pete Carroll expressed his belief in Smith’s potential to improve, emphasizing the need for support around him rather than a swift change.
As teams navigate these challenging decisions, the outcome will not only affect their current season but also shape their future strategies in the league. The performance of starting quarterbacks will be under constant scrutiny as coaches seek to strike a balance between immediate results and long-term development.
