URGENT UPDATE: Australian shares are lagging significantly behind global markets as 2025 nears its end, raising concerns among investors. With only one month left in the year, the ASX 200 has recorded a mere 5% increase, sharply trailing the 15% rise seen in the US market and 25% surge in Japan.
The stark contrast in performance has investors feeling envious, as markets in Europe and China also outperform the ASX. While the ASX is known for its strong dividend payouts, this year’s returns highlight a troubling trend for Australian investors.
Why is the ASX underperforming? Experts cite a heavy reliance on traditional sectors such as banking and mining, which dominate the index. In contrast, US markets are buoyed by tech giants like Nvidia and Apple, which account for approximately 30% of the S&P 500. The Australian market, with only 3% of its index comprised of technology companies, has missed out on the AI-driven investment boom.
Factors contributing to the ASX’s struggles include dwindling prospects for interest rate cuts from the Reserve Bank of Australia, an economy grappling with a cost-of-living crisis, and a downturn in corporate profits. Shane Oliver, chief economist at AMP, notes that earnings per share have stagnated for the past three financial years, reflecting the broader economic challenges.
Despite these hurdles, some analysts remain cautiously optimistic. UBS strategist Richard Schellbach predicts that 2026 could bring the strongest earnings growth for the ASX 200 in four years, driven by a rebound in mining profits. This optimism comes amid fears that US markets may be caught in an AI bubble, which could lead to a more stable environment for the ASX.
However, investor sentiment remains fragile. The Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA), which saw its stock value peak earlier this year, has since dropped nearly 20%. The debate over whether the bank’s valuation is justified reflects broader concerns about the concentration of the Australian market in a few large firms, exposing it to industry-specific risks.
In a year marked by volatility, the traditional strength of the Australian market could provide a safe haven for investors wary of global market fluctuations. As risk appetite returns, however, the ASX continues to trail behind its international counterparts.
As we head into the final month of the year, all eyes will be on the ASX to see if it can recover from its current lag. Investors are urged to stay informed as developments unfold, especially regarding potential earnings growth and market shifts.
For daily updates and insights, subscribe to our Business Briefing newsletter, delivering major stories and expert opinions every weekday morning.
