UPDATE: Bruce Lehrmann is appealing a significant defamation ruling, intensifying the scrutiny surrounding his controversial case following allegations of sexual assault. The former political staffer is challenging the findings made by the Federal Court, which ruled against him in April 2024, stating that the claims made by Brittany Higgins were proven on the balance of probabilities. This legal battle has escalated, and Lehrmann is now fighting to restore his reputation amid mounting public backlash.
In the ruling delivered by Federal Court Justice Michael Lee, he noted, “Having escaped the lions’ den, Mr. Lehrmann made the mistake of going back for his hat,” highlighting the far-reaching implications of this defamation case. Lehrmann’s attorney, Zali Burrows, claims that the media coverage, especially from Channel Ten and journalist Lisa Wilkinson, has transformed him into “probably the most damaged man in Australia.”
The appeal court heard that Lehrmann, aged 30, is now facing extreme public ridicule as a result of the media frenzy. Burrows argued that he was denied procedural fairness because Justice Lee’s findings differed significantly from the case presented by Network Ten. She stated that Lehrmann was surprised by the judge’s characterization of the events, which she described as “non-violent rape,” a term that Justice Craig Colvin found perplexing.
Meanwhile, barrister Matt Collins KC, representing Network Ten, contended that Justice Lee established that Higgins’ rape was indeed violent. He stated, “All rape is violent,” and described Lehrmann’s actions as disrespectful of Higgins’ consent, noting that he continued his assault even after she became aware of the situation.
As the case unfolds, Lehrmann insists he did not assault Higgins, and a criminal trial against him was abandoned in 2022 without any findings. The appeal highlights significant differences in interpretation of consent and the nature of the alleged assault, which has sparked intense debate.
The ongoing media attention and public discourse surrounding this case have led to a surge of negative comments directed at Lehrmann on social media platforms. Burrows emphasized the devastating impact of this scrutiny, stating, “He’s pretty much become a national joke.”
In a dramatic turn of events, the Western Australian Supreme Court is expected to deliver a ruling on the defamation case involving former Liberal senator Linda Reynolds against Higgins next Wednesday, adding another layer of complexity to the unfolding legal saga.
As this story develops, the implications for both Lehrmann and Higgins remain profound, raising questions about media responsibility, public perception, and the legal definitions surrounding consent and sexual violence.
For those affected by sexual abuse or in need of support, the National Sexual Abuse and Redress Support Service is available at 1800 737 732 or 1800 211 028.
