UPDATE: A 33-year-old shoplifter has been fined $500 and ordered to pay $90 in compensation after stealing a bottle of rum from Dan Murphy’s in Bathurst. The ruling was made in the Bathurst Local Court on September 10, 2025, following a series of incidents that highlight the ongoing challenges of retail theft in the area.
Authorities report that Andrew Shepheard was caught on CCTV footage putting a bottle of Old River Rum under his jumper and leaving the store without paying at approximately 2:45 PM on June 30, 2025. This blatant act of theft occurred just weeks after Shepheard completed his parole on May 17, raising concerns about his behavior post-release.
The court session revealed that Shepheard returned to the same store on July 11, 2025, attempting to purchase alcohol, but was denied service by the manager due to his prior theft. During a police visit to his home on July 24, 2025, Shepheard claimed that if he had indeed stolen the rum, it was an honest mistake.
Magistrate Arthur Aguirre addressed the court, stating, “An expensive bottle of rum, sergeant, because it comes with court costs.” He emphasized the seriousness of Shepheard’s actions, indicating that the court was sending a clear message.
Despite Shepheard’s absence in court due to purported health issues related to COVID, he had submitted a guilty plea, demonstrating a willingness to accept responsibility for his actions. Magistrate Aguirre described Shepheard’s situation as “playing with fire,” considering his recent release from parole.
This case underscores the persistent issue of retail theft and its ramifications for both businesses and individuals involved. With shoplifting incidents on the rise, retailers are taking a strong stance against theft, and courts are responding with significant penalties.
As the legal proceedings conclude, many are left wondering what steps will be taken to prevent future incidents and how individuals like Shepheard will navigate their reintegration into society. This case serves as a reminder of the consequences of theft and the importance of accountability.
Stay tuned for more updates on this developing story.
