UPDATE: A controversial proposal in Victoria could see children as young as 14 years old sentenced to up to 25 years in prison for certain violent crimes. Prominent lawyer Hayder Shkara has condemned the plan, labeling it a “knee-jerk” reaction amid rising youth crime concerns.
Authorities are scrambling to address a spike in violent incidents, following the tragic deaths of Ch ol Achiek, 12, and Dau Akueng, 15, who were killed in September while walking home from basketball. The proposal aims to allow young offenders to be tried in the County Court rather than the Children’s Court for serious offenses including aggravated home invasion and carjacking.
Shkara criticized the proposal, stating it is “not fair” and could lead to long-term detrimental effects on community safety. He emphasized that while there has been an uptick in youth crime, the solution should not be locking up young individuals but rather investing in rehabilitation and community initiatives.
The proposed legislation would eliminate the principle of jail as a last resort for minors, compelling judges to prioritize community safety over rehabilitation. Under the new framework, sentences for aggravated home invasion and aggravated carjacking could be increased to life in prison for those aged 14 and older.
The Victorian government plans to introduce this legislation to parliament by the end of 2025, although no specific commencement date has been provided. Shkara fears that the quick fix of incarceration will create a cycle of reoffending, ultimately making society more dangerous.
Critics argue that this approach mirrors legislation passed in Queensland in December 2024, which initially applied to 13 offenses but expanded to 33 offenses by May, including robbery and endangerment of police.
As debate continues, Shkara urges a focus on community-based solutions rather than punitive measures. “We need to be looking out for our community members,” he stated, highlighting the importance of addressing the root causes of youth crime rather than merely reacting to its symptoms.
The Victorian government has indicated that these changes are part of a broader “serious consequences – early interventions” strategy aimed at reducing youth crime. The community awaits further details as the situation develops.
For real-time updates and more information, stay tuned.
